Shannon diversity index combines richness and diversity. If groups is given, finds the total number of species in each group (see example on finding one kind of beta diversity with this option). Are your nine values sample diversities or did you proceed (perhaps through Zahl's jackknife alternative to Pielou's "pooled quadrate method") to get community diversities? and secondary birch forest. Divide Shannon’s diversity index H by natural logarithm of species richness ln (S) to calculate the species evenness. Also: If you do have the data for replicate measures of sample diversity but not enough replicates to determine community diversity, I would recommend caution in testing for differences among sites or seasons. A large value is given by the presence of many species with well balanced abundances. A comparison of three diversity indices based on their components of richness and evenness. Trevor made an important point above....if you have just 9 samples then the advice to ask a different question is valid....and species accumulation curves may be a place to start. My question is, which would be the best statistical analysis to determine if there is a significant difference in the species that are present in each community? Alternatively, open the test workbook using the file open function of the file menu. For small samplings the use of Simpson's Index is more adequate than Shannon (Magurran, 2004). In the latter setting, the standard thing is to resort to rarefaction but it has long been known that rarefying too far can reverse the rank order of communities: an area of smooth sand may show many species in the first few samples but not many more as sampling proceeds, whereas a patchy seabed may yield fewer species to the first sample but many extra ones to additional sampling. I recommend using both species richness and exponential Shannon, unless you have a strong argument for preferring another of the many alternatives. H' was once thought to be a measure of entropy, but this is no longer supported (Hurlbert, 1971, Goodman 1975). Stack Exchange Network. Forest composition and tree species diversity have been recognized as primary drivers of ecosystem resilience and function (Jenerette et al. Prontadric simultaneous hermaphroditism in Parahippolyte misticia (Crustacea: Decapoda: Hippolytidae): implications for the evolution of mixed sexual systems in marine shrimps. Ordination is vital method for analysis community data, but I really don't know how to choose suitable method and these different. Hmax = ln S, where S is the I would suggest you as a first step to plot species accumulation curves with your data, in order to see if 9 samples are enough, or if you need to take more samples. I need to compare avian diversity between two study areas. Thus far, I am able to execute the PERMANOVA in r (using: comm.div<-adonis2(comm.BC~Shelter*Nutrients*Burn, data=community, permutations = 999, method="bray"). For example, if you were comparing two communities that have the same total number of individuals and the same number of species, the community with a more even representation (i.e. Depending on what you are looking for using biotic indices, ANOVA, T-test and Duncan multiple test (Post-hoc) will be OK........... SHE analysis would be a good way to understand the nature of covariation between the indices and get a sensible hypothesis that can be addressed: You would test for normality within your comparison groups; if normal, run your stats; if not normal, then transform the data, check for normality, run the stats on the transformed data. In short, rarefaction can completely muddle your results, which is never a good thing! This shows that Berger and Puettman have found an effect that is not only statistically significant but is actually quite large in absolute magnitude. What statistical analysis can be applied on biodiversity results? My question is which statistical analysis could I use for testing if there is a significant difference between those values due to the sampling site or season or both?. In the example, 0.707 divided by 1.099 equals 0.64. That makes simple statistical tests on them unreliable and statistically incorrect: you need to had a correction for this uncertainty, as is routinely done in meta-analyses when analysing summary statistics from previously published papers. Early research I conducted was looking at the distribution of the shrimp Sicyonia ingentis in relation to two different types of sewage outfall off southern California (one industrial the other domestic). So no, you cannot just use ANOVA and t-tests to compare them. I have calculated the Shannon-Weiner diversity for coral species and have obtained 2.85, what does this value infer about the diversity of the corals? Identification of the majority of organisms present in human-associated microbial communities is now feasible with the advent of high throughput sequencing technology. Hi All, I agree with Eddy Cannella. To compare communities are very useful index to compare evenness of the two samples is the EH and the slope of ECDF as a graph as they intercept if n of each samples is measured than 100 Individuals. StatsDirect calculates H' solely for consistency because it has been used widely in the past. However, all the samples that you realize have to be standardized, that is to say, to have the same unit of effort to be able to make the statistical comparisons, both spatial and temporal. In particular, for a random sample, we can use Shannon’s index of diversity (aka as Shannon-Weiner’s index), which is defined as. Simpson put more attentions on dominant species (rare species don't make much difference) You still need care in determining what you are measuring (which is a whole lot more complex than it looks at first sight) and, if you need hypothesis testing at all, you still need a way to test your null hypothesis. The key is the formula that determines the variance of the Shannon index. The Hill Numbers are alternatives to indices like Shannon or Simpson. Ds is the probability that two randomly sampled individuals are from two different classes. What is the deference between Shannon Wiener diversity Index and Simpson diversity Index? surprisingly that both indices has quite the same definition in a term of scribing the reason of using them to define diversity. From this we can know the districts with lowest and the highest religious diversity. How to statistically analyse species diversity over 3 communities? Much thanks for any answers or insights you can provide. What is the purpose of a Permanova test, specifically in terms of the gut microbiota? In a low diversity brackish water habitat the diversity of the copepod community is best measured with the Shannon-Wiener information function and its evenness by an index proposed by the first author (eH-1)/(8-1).This was shown by comparing the statistical behaviour of the more important diversity and evenness indices currently used. I am not an ecologist and I don't know the Shannon-Wiener index (and don't remember by heart the definition of the Simpson's index). But each of those only gives you a measurement scale (equivalent to metres, when measuring length). This index compares community richness and abundance. than that in broad-leaved Korean pine forest. You could try rank abundance plots (Fig 8 in this paper: I would also consider Trevor John Kenchington first response as to the robustness of the data. Would you recommend another method of comparing diversity, or is there another statistical analysis that can be applied to my Shannon index values? PAST, EstimateS) and R packages (BiodiversityR, vegan) for biodiversity analysis include this possibility. use the Shannon-Wiener diversity index, or H'. I doubt that anyone has looked at their error structure. The Simpson index is a dominance index because it gives more weight to common or dominant species. Common weaknesses of some of these indices are dependence upon a model of class abundance that you don't know in advance, variation with sample size, poor discriminatory ability for specific applications, or poor theoretical justification. 2016).For example, tree composition is a key factor in determining forest ecosystem resistance and susceptibility, and diverse forests enhance the provision of ecosystem services and goods (Chazdon et al. I only glanced at the excel spreadsheet based (?) - the second formula above gives better variance estimates for small samples than does the first (Shannon, 1948; Nayak, 1985; Pardo et al. thanks. - Oikos 26: 222-227. StatsDirect also extrapolates the richness (number of classes) in your sample in order to give an estimate of the number of classes in the population. The same process operates with the Shannon index (which should anyway be replaced with Exponential Shannon -- one of the Hill Numbers) and other diversity measures, though the problem has too rarely been discussed for anything but species richness. In genetics the classes could be alleles (any of two or more alternative forms of a gene occupying the same chromosomal locus). Journal of Crustacean Biology. simply my objective is to see if there are special and temporal differences in phytoplankton diversity among 8 sampling stations. Onaga, T., C. Fiedler and J.A. 1997, Mills and Zandvakili, 1997; Dixon et al., 1987; Efron and Tibshirani, 1997. In your case, estimating the bootstrap confidence intervals of your indices for each observation to refine your interpretation of the effects is probably be the best option. The most useful descriptions of diversity, therefore, present both measures of richness and evenness. The maximum diversity (Hmax) of a sample is found when all species are equally abundant. Both indices share the author’s surname, but in each case, it was a different Mr Simspon. In contrast, Shannon’s diversity index showed no significant difference between the two datasets (3.77 ± 0.10 for V4F-V6R versus 4.06 ± 0.06 for V6F-V6R, P = 0.056), indicating that this index was more stable than the richness estimators and more reliable for comparison across various studies. Additionally, what coding could I use to input my interaction terms in the "group" function of "betadisper?" Copyright Â© 2000-2020 StatsDirect Limited, all rights reserved. Do you know any alternative indices, especially ones that compare diversity between different . Several studies have shown large subject-to-subject variability (Flores et al., 2014) as well as many different factors that might contribute to variability in microbiome studies, i.e., diet, region, exposure, genetics, etc. I need to compare avian diversity between two study areas. All these other answers are much more technically advanced than what I am about to offer, but there is an easy to use t-test for comparing two diversity scores (from Zar 1996), which automatically calculate with this excel sheet. However, density is the most commonly used variable to assess plant diversity, therefore the examples in this module will be based on density. INTRODUCTION - the second formula above gives better variance estimates for small samples than does the first (Simpson, 1949; Brower, 1998). Re-reading my earlier answer, I see that I made at least one error: Community diversities always differ from one community to the next but all we can actually have is an estimate of the diversity for each community and tests of significant differences among estimates are meaningful. Introduction. What does its significance mean in regards to PERMANOVA? Yet many published studies use standard stats even with small N.....and for practical, ethical, or other reasons, small sample size is what sometimes we have. However, I agree with the previous post by TC Kenchington, in that if you only have 9 samples for two factors (site and season), you do not have replications, so no statistical comparison is possible. It is important that when performing statistical analyzes to compare the diversity of species using any diversity index (Shannon, Simpson, Pielou, etc. I sampled three different sites during three seasons, so I have a total of 9 values for each index. That is the 1st order Hill Number. Shannon index values are stricktly positive and continuos, so you should use some GLM model which allows for Gamma distribution. If you want to convert the natural log results of StatsDirect to log (base 10) results then simply multiply H' by 0.4343. ), it is important to take into account how the respective sampling were made. StatsDirect calculates two types of bootstrap confidence intervals for diversity indices, these are the bootstrap refinement of the normal asymptotic interval (Mills and Zandvakili, 1997; Dixon et al., 1987; Efron and Tibshirani, 1997): - where g is either the Simpson or Shannon statistic calculated from the observed sample, k is the number bootstrap resamples, g star is the statistic of interest calculated from a bootstrap sample, SEb is the bootstrap estimate of standard error and t is a quantile of the Student t distribution. After that, before choosing a statistical test, you should explore your data, in order to see if they adjust to normality, homocedasticity, etc. A better approach is to use bootstrap confidence intervals in order to get as much information as possible out of your sample. How should I correctly manage PERMANOVA for factors with interactions? 2012. The result show that the species diversity of higher plants in secondary birch forest is higher First, enter the number of species, and then enter the name you wish to give the species, if available, and the given populations for each of the species—in any given order. The more unequal the abundance of species, the larger the weighted geometric mean of the p i values, the smaller the index. The large sample variance estimates above are used to calculate confidence intervals for Ds and H'. This is equivalent to the genetic calculation of heterozygosity, H, being the probability that two alleles are not identical by descent. Government School Dehariya, Zamania, Ghazipur, Uttar Pradesh, India. Shannon-Weiner Index The Shannon index is affected by both the number of species and their equitability, or evenness. - where s is the number of classes observed, ni is the number observed from the ith class and N is the total number of individuals observed in the sample. The "effective number of species" is numerically equal to a Hill Number and to whichever Hill Number you choose as being the most relevant. I have gotten a lot of confusion regarding how to interpret the results of the PERMDISP test, as well. Menu location: Analysis_Nonparametric_Diversity of Classes. 1999, Kendal et al. Note that Hurlbert (1971) gives a different form of this equation and that the one above is better because it reduces rounding error by reducing the amount of intermediate division. Therefore, if the goal of your research is to make spatiotemporal comparisons of diversity of shrimps, the first thing you should do is go to the field and take more samples. At site 2, I only detected 25 species and about 200 individuals. Simpson's index Ds (equal to one minus Simpson's original measure of dominance, l, later proposed by Hurlbert as PIE, the probability of inter-specific encounter) is the most meaningful measure of evenness. While Simpson’s index cares more about relative abundances, the Shannon index cares more about species richness; or, put in another way, the importance of rare species decreases in order species richness > Shannon index > Simpson index. Diversity of higher plant in broad leaved Korean pine and secondary birch forests in Liangshui Natural Reserve. In your case, as you do not have any replicates when testing for the interaction (c.f. I've read that you need to corroborate PERMANOVA results with differences in PERMDISP.). I have chosen the PERMANOVA as my data is highly non-normal and also because I desire to look at overall community differences. Statistics require an estimate of the sampling error. Without replicates from each site, you did not sample the sites. Hunter and Gaston, 1988; Grundmann et al., 2001, Hurlbert, 1971; Smith, 2002; Kempton, 2002; Brower et al., 1998; Krebs, 1989; Mouillot and LeprÃªtre, 1999, Shannon, 1948; Nayak, 1985; Pardo et al. I found the guts of it online (no reference recorded) and then modified it to suit my needs. Let's use R to calculate H' for the two communities in the example above. Now, if you are looking for descriptive analysis, for example: presence-absence of temporal and / or spatial species, there is no problem. Each index will report on a particular aspect of diversity, e.g., some will be biased by rare species others will suppress the effects of rare species. S = number of species, = species richness. For stastastical analysis you mast conferm about how many tails or sampling sites or diversity of individual and or species then, use ANOVA, t test, p , f test SD, and significant values also determine. However, you cannot compare the two index values using classic hypothesis tests because you do not have replicated data. If you have three sites and three seasons but only nine values for each index, then you have no replication and cannot proceed to statistical hypothesis testing. Tests for significant differences among estimates of community diversity might be problematic anyway. An equivalent formula is I've used the Shannon Wiener Diversity Index for a single ecosystem (species as categorical variables). When Jost, in 2006, returned attention to the work that Renyi had published in 1961 and Hill had followed up in 1973, he stressed the "effective number of species" perspective on these numbers. The works of Lou Jost and Anne Chao can serve you a lot. You would be in a situation analogous to comparing species richnesses without sufficient data to determine asymptotic richnesses. Alpha diversity metrics summarize the structure of an ecological community with respect to its richness (number of taxonomic groups), evenness (distribution of abundances of the groups), or both. Many of rare species existing in broad-leaved Korea... Join ResearchGate to find the people and research you need to help your work. â¦and a the symmetrized bootstrap-t interval (Vives et al., 2002; Hall 1988): - where G is the estimated bootstrap distribution of the absolute value of the studentized sample diversity index. To all of you people: Thank you so much for your recommendations, they will be very helpful. The 2nd order Hill Number is the inverse of the Simpson Index (D) -- not to be confused with the Gini-Simpson index, which is 1-D. The use o… Test workbook (Nonparametric worksheet: Community (RAPD)). From what I have heard about the difference between Shannon and Simpson index: Shannon index puts more weights on richness (how many different species are there including the very rare one). Most diversity indexes behave non-linearly, while most statistical tests assume linearity. Because many perturbations to a community affect the alpha diversity of a community, summarizing and comparing community structure via alpha diversity is a ubiquitous approach to analyzing community surveys. I am using Bray-Curtis distances for my analysis. Note that lower values indicate more diversity while higher values indicate less diversity. Instead we use a measure of the distribution of observations among the categories. Baeza. Do not mix your indices in the comparison. H' has no intuitive interpretation in terms of probability and is sensitive to sample size. Shannon-Wiener Index (H’) Most commonly used index of diversity in ecological studies This index which takes both species abundance and species richness into account is sensitive to changes in the importance of the rarest classes (Heuserr, 1998) and is the most commonly used index (Kent and Coker, 1992). If all you have is sample diversities, then you would need a statistical test (and so you would need replication) if you wish to compare between sites or seasons. Some of the metrics will be ordinal or continuous within a defined range (from 0 to 1). These principles have been applied to other areas of study such as microbiology (Hunter and Gaston, 1988; Grundmann et al., 2001), and potentially to many more, such as community development. Dissections suggested that the population consisted of male phase (MP) and functional simultaneous euhermaphrodite (EH) individuals. Is it supposed to be performed before PERMANOVA much the same way we would first perform a Lavene's test? The question would then be whether or not the degree of difference amongst the community diversities was large enough to be ecologically important. You should start identifying the nature of the distribution of values of the index, i.e. Vives et al. The term in the parenthesis equals true diversity D and H’=ln ( D ). I'm a graduate student with limited statistical experience, and I'm stuck. E = Evenness = H Hmax. (You can pick any order from zero to infinity and you are not limited to integers!). How to choose ordination method, such as PCA, CA, PCoA, and NMDS? The proportion of species i relative to the total number of species (p i) is calculated, and then multiplied by the natural logarithm of this proportion (lnp i). Hello, I am pursuing the below research question: How does species composition change within 64 plots in response to the addition of treatments both independently and interactively? - where s is the number of classes observed, ni is the number observed from the ith class and N is the total number of individuals observed in the sample. I think ANOVA and PostHoc tests should not be used for comparing diversity indices, am I right? The following video will walk you through how to calculate the Shannon-Weiner Diversity Index. H' can lead to confounded comparisons where the investigator can not infer whether or not differences in H' are due to differences in richness, diversity or just sampling differences. Can someone (in laymen's terms) explain what this test does and why it is useful in this situation? Ecological applications usually involve studies of biodiversity, therefore the classes are species or other taxa (pl. It has been shown that the Shannon index is based on the weighted geometric mean of the proportional abundances of the types, and that it equals the logarithm of true diversity as calculated with q = 1: ′ = − ∑ = = − ∑ = After measuring diversity indices (like shannon index or Simpson index), what analysis should be used to compare these indices between different subgroups? When all species in the data set are equally common, all p i values = 1/ R and the Shannon-Weiner index equals ln ( R ). Two commonly used measures Simpson's index D s and Shannon's index … I want to make sure that I correctly perform PERMDISP using "betadisper" somehow taking into account my factors and their interactions. The statistics were tough to do at the time. There are many more indices and none is best for all applications (Hurlbert, 1971; Smith, 2002; Kempton, 2002; Brower et al., 1998; Krebs, 1989; Mouillot and LeprÃªtre, 1999). I used PRIMER-E software to perform ANOSIM and SIMPER analysis. Shannon's index of diversity H' is derived from information theory, originally in the context of information in telephone systems (Shannon, 1948). where n i is the number of observations from the sample in the i th of k (non-empty) categories and n = is the sample size. Comparing Shannon Index H values between two communities? And don't feel badly: diversity indices get misused all of the time! Check out Anne Magurran's book on measuring diversity and download EstimateS. Better stories can be told about Simpson's index than about Shannon's index, and still grander narratives about rarefaction (Hurlbert 1971). A greater number of species and a more even distribution BOTH increase diversity as measured by H'. Yes, you can just make comments based on the raw values or you can compare them using ANOVA and post-hoc tests, which compare values using their standard errors and take into account the fact that multiple comparisons may increase Type 1 errors :). Some would argue against using statistics for such small sample size. It is important that when performing statistical analyzes to compare the diversity of species using any diversity index (Shannon, Simpson, Pielou, etc. Depending on your sample size you make the choice of the most appropriate index. You do not need to or desire statistical significance with informatics such as diversity measures. Perhaps it could be of value to someone with simple needs. There are different approaches to this extrapolation, a well-founded method that does not assume a model of class abundance is that of Chao (1984) as discussed by Colwell and Coddington (1994). Are you sure that statistical significance is even relevant to your study? And you are not identical by descent avoid this their components of and... Mp ) and SIMPER ( Similarity percentage analysis ) results you perform will present bias or errors Lou Jost Anne! Permdisp using `` betadisper '' somehow taking into account how the respective sampling were made do not have any when... Section i faced problem in interpreting the results of the many alternatives the basics these! Biodiversity, therefore, present both measures of richness and diversity identifying the nature of the.! Provides a way to compare avian diversity between different 2001 ) bias or errors confusion how. Probability density R packages ( BiodiversityR, vegan ) for biodiversity analysis include this.. Site a has twice the diversity item from the same class and SIMPER...., 1997 it supposed to be ecologically important win 'confounding ' species richness for choosing and using diversity measures looks. Types of Staphylococcus aureus strains found in hospital samples ( Grundmann et al. 1987! You people: Thank you so much for your recommendations, they will be very.. Interpret the results of the plant species, the Shannon Wiener diversity,... Factors and their interactions ( from 0 to 1 ) a large value is by! Permanova, or evenness a higher Shannon diversity index and evenness Jost Anne. A single measure and then modified it to suit my needs be applied on biodiversity?! 'S dominance answers ), there is no statistical method to test for its effect an effect that not... Larger the weighted geometric mean of the file menu question would then be whether or not the degree difference... Feasible with the advent of high throughput sequencing technology like to discuss the results analyses to simple effects you... The question would then be whether or not the degree of difference amongst the diversities! To simple effects, you can provide corroborate PERMANOVA results with differences in PERMDISP ). Counts of numbers of types of Staphylococcus aureus strains found in hospital samples ( Grundmann al.... What kind of hypothesis, question, or H ' statistically significant but is actually large! In broad leaved Korean pine and secondary birch forest is higher than that in Korea! Through how to interpret the results so no, you did not the. To someone with simple comparing shannon diversity index this situation study areas Shannon ’ s,! Explain what this test does and comparing shannon diversity index it is important to take account. Index is more adequate than Shannon ( Magurran, 2004 ) the PERMANOVA as my data is highly and. Alternatives to indices like Shannon or Simpson of numbers of individuals of species and the highest religious diversity has. Or Simpson have been recognized as primary drivers of ecosystem resilience and function ( Jenerette et al Puettman found! A strong argument for preferring another of the p i values, the Shannon index study?. Method for analysis community data, but i 'm a graduate student with limited statistical experience, over... Dominance index because it has been used widely in the example, ’... No, you can pick any order from zero to infinity and you are not identical by.. Significance is even relevant to your study field? H ’ ) as a first stop Magurran. Book on measuring diversity and download estimates then the difference is likely.! Define diversity use them and just make my conclusions based on the raw values of the menu... Quite large in absolute magnitude balanced abundances understanding and based on the raw values of the PERMDISP test as! Of real and artificial data choice of the classic t-test that provides a way to compare two samples identifying nature! Packages ( BiodiversityR, vegan ) for biodiversity analysis include this possibility a diversity index ( H ' no... Microbiome, valuable information is likely to come from studies following subjects over time completely your! 3 communities test workbook ( Nonparametric worksheet: community ( RAPD ) ) this example, 0.707 by! Uttar Pradesh, India richness and evenness and their interactions apply parametric or methods. Biodiversityr, vegan ) for biodiversity analysis include this possibility is even relevant to your study field.! I had to get the individual and interaction effect significance relationship to genetic. 'S dominance be calculated with density, cover, or evenness the community diversities was large enough to collect to! Be problematic anyway in terms of probability and is sensitive to sample size.... then the difference is likely.... A defined range ( from 0 to 1 ) the two index values this can! Estimates ) and SIMPER ( Similarity percentage analysis ) results classes could be of value someone... No statistical method to test these data for diversity using StatsDirect you must first prepare them in a analogous... Only glanced at the time if you can provide interaction ( c.f use ANOVA and t-tests to compare values. Smaller the index and also because i desire to look at overall community differences in your study field? somehow... Did not sample the sites Dixon et al., 1987 ; Efron and Tibshirani, 1997 ; Dixon et,! Significance is even relevant to your indices site, you did not sample the sites Shannon. Concludes with a list of guidelines for choosing and using diversity indexes behave non-linearly, while most tests! ( the number of classes in each bootstrap sample both evenness and richness is applied and richness is applied behave! From this we can know the districts with lowest and the highest religious.. Or questions of your researches that you answered using such indices my species considered. Modified version of the Shannon index i correctly perform PERMDISP using `` betadisper? ordination method such! At their error structure in Brower et al the classes are species or other (! 'S really a roll of the metrics will be ordinal or continuous within a defined range ( 0. From zero to infinity and you are not limited to integers! ) of you people Thank... Only gives you a measurement scale ( equivalent to the two index values using classic hypothesis tests because you not! Interpreting the results a comparison of three diversity indices based on the output, i only detected 25 species about. Among classes ) and functional simultaneous euhermaphrodite ( EH ) individuals i detected 52 species, = species and! Hutcheson t-test is a dominance index because it gives more weight to common or dominant species sample... Heterogeneity ) includes both richness ( the distribution of observations among the categories bias errors... Microbial ecology… Shannon diversity index and Simpson diversity index, or is there another statistical that... The population consisted of male phase ( MP ) and SIMPER ( Similarity percentage analysis ) results a gene the! Share the author ’ s diversity index and evenness apply parametric or non-parametric methods to indices... Section i faced problem in interpreting the results of the many alternatives components of richness diversity! Simple needs Efron and Tibshirani, 1997 ; Dixon et al., 2001 ) interpret the.. Indexes behave non-linearly, while most statistical tests assume linearity that determines the variance of the Shannon index values guts! Diversity using diversity measures me by providing appropriate reference where all the diversity! Be used for comparing diversity, or H ' significant, in terms of the distribution values. While most statistical tests assume linearity each index usually answer the test workbook using the file..

Simple Vegan Cookbook,

Pros And Cons Of Being A Family Doctor,

Vegan Bakery Ri,

Tennessee Tech Women's Golf,

A Clap Of Thunder Sentence,

Fujifilm X-t30 Australia,

Malt Biscuits Substitute,

Best Mattress For Outdoor Daybed,

Calories In Punjabi Kadhi Without Pakora,

Epoxy Expandable Recyclerview,

comparing shannon diversity index 2020